Substitute for Vegetable Oil in Brownies: 16 Options

Last updated on February 5th, 2026

Generally, brownie recipes include vegetable oil as the primary fat in brownie batter, to produce that fudgy texture we all know and adore. But when the vegetable oil has vanished from your pantry, don’t panic. Pick the best substitute for vegetable oil in brownies, promising scrumptious results in any brownie recipe.

Can You Bake Brownies Without Vegetable Oil?

You can substitute it 1:1 with butter, coconut oil, canola oil, or olive oil for similar results.

For healthier options, try applesauce (use 3/4 the amount), mashed bananas (use 3/4 the amount), or Greek yogurt (1:1 ratio).

Each substitute affects flavor and texture differently – butter adds richness, coconut oil gives tropical notes, and fruit purees reduce calories while adding moisture.

Quick FAQ

What’s the easiest 1:1 substitute for vegetable oil in brownies? Melted butter, coconut oil, canola oil, or olive oil work perfectly as direct replacements.

Can I make brownies healthier by substituting the oil? Yes! Try applesauce, mashed bananas, or Greek yogurt to reduce calories and add nutrients.

Will my brownies taste different with substitutes? Some will – coconut oil adds tropical flavor, butter makes them richer, and olive oil gives a subtle fruity taste. Canola oil tastes most neutral.

What happens if I use no oil at all? Your brownies will be dry, dense, and crumbly. Oil provides essential moisture and structure.

Which substitute makes the fudgiest brownies? Butter or coconut oil create the most fudgy texture, while fruit purees make them more cake-like.

Best Substitutes to Use for Beginners

1. Butter (Most Popular)

• Why it works: Contains fat and water for moisture and richness
• Pro tip: Use melted butter for easier mixing
• Result: Richer flavor, slightly more cake-like texture than oil

2. Coconut Oil

• Why it works: High fat content similar to vegetable oil
• Pro tip: Use refined coconut oil for less coconut flavor
• Result: Subtle tropical taste, very fudgy texture

3. Olive Oil

• Why it works: Monounsaturated fats provide moisture
• Pro tip: Use light olive oil for milder flavor
• Result: Slightly fruity taste that complements chocolate

4. Avocado Oil

• Why it works: High smoke point and neutral flavor
• Pro tip: More expensive but heart-healthy option
• Result: Clean taste, excellent moisture retention

Vegetable Oil Substitute Table

Take a look at the table below, outlining the different substitutes, followed by the appropriate requirements to successfully replace vegetable oil.

Substitute	Ratio	Flavor Impact	Texture Result	Best For
Margarine	1:1	Mild buttery	Rich, chocolatey	Butter alternative
Olive Oil	1:1	Slightly fruity	Moist, tender	Sophisticated flavor
Canola Oil	1:1	Neutral	Similar to original	Heart-healthy option
Avocado Oil	1:1	Neutral	Moist, fudgy	Health-conscious baking
Sunflower Oil	1:1	Neutral	Light, fluffy	Allergen-friendly
Coconut Oil	1:1	Subtle coconut	Fudgy, moist	Tropical twist
Mashed Bananas	3/4 amount	Banana flavor	Dense, moist	Natural sweetness
Butter	1:1	Rich, buttery	Fudgy, dense	Classic brownies
Applesauce	3/4 amount	Mild sweetness	Cake-like, moist	Low-fat option
Fruit Puree	1:1 (reduce liquid by 1/2)	Varies by fruit	Moist, dense	Creative flavors
Vanilla Extract	Start with 1/2 tsp	Enhanced vanilla	Flavor enhancer only	Flavor boost
Greek Yogurt	1:1	Tangy	Moist, slightly dense	Protein boost
Buttermilk	1/2 amount	Tangy	Tender, fluffy	Reducing baking time
Cornstarch	1:1 (mix with water first)	Neutral	Binding agent	Thickening substitute
Mayonnaise	1:1	Neutral	Incredibly moist	Emergencies and moisture
Peanut Butter	1:1	Nutty	Dense, fudgy	Protein-packed

Tips for Perfect Substitution

Before You Start

1. Bring ingredients to room temperature for easier mixing
2. Measure accurately – baking is science
3. Read the full recipe before making substitutions

During Mixing

1. Don’t overmix – this creates tough brownies
2. Combine wet and dry ingredients separately first
3. Fold ingredients together gently

Baking Adjustments

• Fruit purees: May need 5-10 minutes less baking time
• Buttermilk: Reduce baking time by 10 minutes
• Thick substitutes: May need slightly lower temperature

Testing for Doneness

• Toothpick test: Should come out with a few moist crumbs
• Visual cues: Edges should pull slightly from pan
• Touch test: Center should spring back lightly

15 Vegetable Oil Substitutes for Brownies

If you’ve run out of this crucial ingredient, or simply aren’t a fan, you can opt for a variety of alternatives listed below (some of them healthier options).

1. Margarine
2. Olive oil
3. Canola oil
4. Avocado oil
5. Sunflower oil
6. Coconut oil
7. Mashed Bananas
8. Butter
9. Applesauce
10. Fruit puree
11. Vanilla extract
12. Greek yogurt
13. Buttermilk
14. Cornstarch
15. Mayonnaise
16. Peanut Butter

1. Margarine

Margarine has a mild buttery taste, that assures a sweetened, rich chocolatey flavor in your brownie recipe. This is why it is a perfect substitute for vegetable oil. While it’s mostly enjoyed when spread on toast or crackers, it is often used in place of butter.

Substitute 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil for 1 tablespoon of margarine, to achieve that silky chocolatey interior in your brownies.

2. Olive Oil

Try substituting 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil with 1 tablespoon of olive oil in your brownie recipe instead.

Olive oil, and its types, is one of the ingredients used in vegetable oil, which is why it makes such a fantastic replacement.

3. Canola Oil

Canola oil contains many health benefits. This is why canola is such a great vegetable oil substitute. With very low saturated fats and lots of nutrients, this super oil is especially amazing when added to baked goods, as it promises the enhancement of heart health.

Simply substitute 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil for 1 tablespoon of canola oil in your brownie batter.

4. Avocado Oil

Avocado oil is a welcome ingredient for a variety of meals, including pan-fried dishes and baked goods. Since it’s known for providing many health benefits, it also makes a great substitute for vegetable oil.

When replacing vegetable oil with avocado oil, use a 1:1 ratio, i.e. 1 tablespoon of avocado oil for 1 cup of vegetable oil.

5. Sunflower Oil

Made from sunflower seeds, sunflower oil is another ingredient used in vegetable oil. This makes it such an incredible substitute for brownies and other baked goods.

Simply add 1 tablespoon of sunflower oil in place of 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil.

6. Coconut Oil

Coconut oil is by far one of the best vegetable oil substitutes. While coconut isn’t exactly a subtle ingredient, it does provide your recipes with a comforting coconutty flavor.

Substitute 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil for 1 tablespoon of coconut oil in your brownies recipe.

7. Mashed Bananas

For a unique and creamy twist to your chocolate fudgy brownies, try substituting mashed bananas for vegetable oil in your recipes.

Use ¾ of pureed bananas for every 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil used in the brownie recipe.

8. Butter

Butter is almost an automatic substitute for vegetable oil, especially in baked goods. When you’re craving a rich, tender, and moist brownie, you’ll need butter and lots of it.

Add a tablespoon of melted butter in place of vegetable oil when making brownies.

9. Applesauce

Applesauce is both delicious and a healthy substitute for vegetable oil in your brownies. You can whip up a fresh batch of this delicious sauce at home, or buy a jar from the supermarket.

If you’re planning to use applesauce in your brownie recipe, decrease the sugar, and substitute 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil for ¾ tablespoon of applesauce.

10. Fruit Puree

Use mild-flavored fruits like avocado or banana, to produce a pleasant neutral brownie, though you can experiment with anything you fancy.

To do this you’ll need to replace 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil with 1 tablespoon of fruit puree and decrease other liquid ingredients by half.

11. Vanilla Extract

Vanilla extract is a key element in many dessert recipes. Without it, desserts would lose their glorious fragrance. Though vanilla extract doesn’t contribute to the texture, it happens to make your treats taste a thousand times better.

12. Greek Yogurt

With a distinct tartness that seems to dance on your tongue, Greek yogurt is assumed to clash with chocolate flavors in brownie recipes.

Replace 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil with 1 tablespoon of yogurt. For a healthier approach to this brownie recipe, opt for nonfat or plain yogurt.

13. Buttermilk

Another creamy element to include as a potential substitution for vegetable oil is buttermilk.

When using buttermilk in your brownies, substitute 1 tablespoon of vegetable oil for ½ a tablespoon of buttermilk, and reduce the baking time by 10 minutes.

14. Cornstarch

Many people eat cornstarch. Surprisingly, cornstarch also happens to be an ideal substitute for vegetable oil.

You won’t be able to add cornstarch straight to the brownie mix like the other substitutes. Instead, mix some water with the cornstarch and heat it until it achieves the appropriate consistency.

Once this has cooled, pour this over the brownie mixture. Substitute 1 cup of vegetable oil for one cup of this cooked cornstarch.

15. Mayonnaise

Mayonnaise has an incredibly creamy texture that is loaded with omega-3 fats. With the addition of mayo, your brownies will emerge creamier, and more delicious. This makes mayonnaise an excellent replacement for vegetable oil.

You’ll typically substitute the mayonnaise at a 1:1 ratio.

16. Peanut Butter

With its rich, nutty flavor and creamy texture, peanut butter makes for a delicious, protein-packed substitute for vegetable oil in brownies. Simply use a 1:1 ratio, swapping the vegetable oil for natural peanut butter, to maintain moisture and binding power. However, peanut butter’s thicker consistency compared to liquid oils will impact texture.

For best results, replace about 1/4 cup flour with extra peanut butter to achieve fudgy brownies bursting with peanutty appeal. And while peanut butter contains some saturated fats, it primarily delivers heart-healthy monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats along with 7 grams of protein per tablespoon.

How Each Substitute Affects Your Brownies

Flavor Changes

• Neutral: Canola oil, avocado oil, mayonnaise, applesauce
• Enhanced: Butter (richer), coconut oil (tropical), olive oil (fruity)
• Distinctive: Banana (fruity), Greek yogurt (tangy), peanut butter (nutty)

Texture Changes

• Fudgier: Butter, coconut oil, peanut butter
• More cake-like: Applesauce, mashed bananas, buttermilk
• Similar to original: Canola oil, avocado oil, olive oil

Nutritional Impact

• Added fiber: Fruit purees
• Higher protein: Greek yogurt, peanut butter
• Lower calories: Applesauce, mashed bananas
• Heart-healthy fats: Avocado oil, olive oil

Mistakes and Troubleshooting

Measurement Errors

• Don’t guess ratios – follow the substitution chart
• Level your measurements for accuracy
• Account for density differences in thick substitutes

Temperature Issues

• Don’t use cold butter – it won’t mix properly
• Solid coconut oil needs to be melted first
• Hot ingredients can cook eggs prematurely

Flavor Missteps

• Too much vanilla extract can overpower chocolate
• Strong olive oil can clash with chocolate
• Overly ripe bananas can make brownies too sweet

Dry Brownies

• Cause: Not enough fat substitute or overbaking
• Solution: Add 1-2 tablespoons of milk or cream

Too Dense

• Cause: Heavy substitutes like nut butter
• Solution: Add 1-2 tablespoons of milk to lighten

Weird Flavor

• Cause: Strong-flavored substitute
• Solution: Use neutral oils or reduce amount

Won’t Set

• Cause: Too much liquid substitute
• Solution: Add 1-2 tablespoons of flour

Storage Tips by Substitute

Butter-Based Brownies

• Store covered at room temperature for 3 days
• Refrigerate for up to 1 week
• Freeze for up to 3 months

Fruit Puree Brownies

• Store in refrigerator (higher moisture content)
• Consume within 4-5 days
• May become soggy if left out

Oil-Based Brownies

• Longest shelf life of all substitutes
• Best for gifting or meal prep
• Room temperature storage for up to 1 week

Vegetable Oil’s Role in Baking

• Moisture retention: Keeps brownies from drying out
• Texture creation: Produces that signature fudgy, dense consistency
• Binding agent: Helps ingredients stick together
• Neutral flavor: Won’t compete with chocolate taste
• Shelf life: Extends freshness compared to butter-based recipes

Vegetable oil is a popular option for cooking. It doesn’t leave a dent in your pocket and provides a neutral flavor. The latter makes it so great for use in almost any recipe.

Apart from brownies, there are a wide variety of baked goods (such as bread or muffins) that have vegetable oil as an essential ingredient.

Benefits of Substituting Vegetable Oil in Brownies

Replacing vegetable oil with healthier alternatives when baking brownies can offer numerous advantages. From enhancing nutrition to improving texture and catering to dietary needs, incorporating substitutes provides brownies with a nutritious makeover.

Boosts Nutritional Value

Swapping out vegetable oil for options like mashed bananas, Greek yogurt, or applesauce amplifies the nutritional value of brownies. These substitutes pack in extra vitamins, minerals, and fiber compared to plain oil. For example, bananas provide potassium, yogurt contains protein and probiotics, and applesauce boasts antioxidants. Using substitutes enables you to transform brownies from an indulgent treat into a more wholesome, nourishing snack.

Enhances Flavor

Some vegetable oil alternatives like coconut oil, butter, or fruit purees lend rich depth and dimension to the taste of brownies. Coconut oil provides subtle tropical flair, butter boosts buttery vanilla notes, and fruit purees like avocado or banana introduce creaminess and natural sweetness. Experimenting with different substitutes allows you to customize flavors and create brownies catered to your palate.

Improves Texture

Swap out vegetable oil for substitutes like avocado oil or butter to achieve ultra-moist and fudgy brownie texture. The high smoke points of avocado oil prevent overbaking, while the water content in butter creates excellent moisture retention. Substitutes can also add denseness, fluffiness, or smoothness depending on what you use. Getting texture just right takes testing, but the payoff of gooey, melt-in-your-mouth brownies makes it worthwhile.

Considerations When Substituting Vegetable Oil

When choosing a substitute for vegetable oil in your brownies, there are a few key factors to consider so your baked treats turn out perfect. You want to account for potential changes in taste, texture, nutrition, and necessary adjustments to the baking process.

Impact on Taste and Texture

Some substitutes like coconut oil or butter can infuse new flavors, while others like canola or avocado oil aim to mimic the neutral taste of vegetable oil. The thickness of the substitute used also affects moisture, fudginess, and density. Test bakes are helpful to see how specific substitutes impact your brownie’s final texture and flavor.

Allergens and Dietary Needs

If you or your guests have food allergies or dietary restrictions like nut allergies, dairy intolerance, or a vegan diet, scrutinize substitutes accordingly. For example, sunflower seed oil contains no dairy or nuts. Get ingredient lists and read labels carefully.

Interactions and Baking Adjustments

Substituting vegetable oil causes a ripple effect with other ingredients in the recipe. For instance, using yogurt instead of oil allows you to reduce sugar content. Baking time and temperature may also need tweaks with substitutes that impact moisture and density. Taking notes while experimenting will help perfect your brownie recipe.

How to Substitute Vegetable Oil in Brownies

Here’s a delicious brownie recipe, that replaces vegetable oil with butter. You can use this recipe and replace butter with any of the alternatives listed above.

Ingredients

• 10 tbsp unsalted butter (to replace vegetable oil)
• 1 ¼ cups granulated sugar
• ¾ cup unsweetened cocoa powder
• ¼ tsp salt
• ½ tsp vanilla extract
• 2 large eggs
• ½ cup all-purpose flour

Instructions

1. Preheat the oven to 325 degrees F.
2. Prepare an 8-inch square baking pan with parchment paper and set aside.
3. Add water 1 cup of water to a saucepan, and heat till it’s almost simmering.
4. Add butter, sugar, cocoa powder, and salt in a medium heat-safe bowl. Allow the bowl to rest over simmering water, stirring the mixture occasionally, until the butter has melted and the mixture is warm.
5. Remove the bowl and set it aside for 3 to 5 minutes. The mixture should be warm, and not hot. Then stir in vanilla extract, and add the eggs one by one, stirring constantly.
6. Next, add the flour and stir, then beat the mixture with a wooden spoon until you achieve the desired consistency.
7. Bake the brownies for 20 to 25 minutes.

Vegetable Oil Substitutes – A Lot!

The numerous substitutes for vegetable oil promise a delicious bake so that you can enjoy your brownies without feeling the heavy absence of your favorite cooking oil.

For more substitution ideas, check out my blog:

• Egg Substitutes for Brownies
• Eggless Brownies
• Substitutes for Bananas in Baking
• Substitute for Oil in Pancakes

Substitute For Vegetable Oil In Brownies – FAQs

Print