Can I Use Yeast Instead Of Baking Powder? Surprising Answer

Published Categorized as Ingredients, Journal


Yeast and baking powder both work in very similar ways. They are both commonly used in baking. If they are used in the same way – to make cakes rise – can I use yeast instead of baking powder? This is a complicated one! With some recipes you can and some recipes, it may not be that easy!

In this article we will look at how to replace yeast with baking powder and also, how to replace baking powder with yeast.

Hey there! This site is reader-supported and I earn commissions if you purchase products from retailers after clicking on a link from this site.

Replace Baking Powder With Yeast

Can I use baking powder instead of instant yeast? The answer is complicated as it really depends on what you are baking.

You can use any ingredient as a substitute for another but it does not necessarily mean that the results will be that great. Luckily baking powder and yeast work very similarly so there is the possibility of replacing them for one another.

It is easier to replace yeast with baking powder than it is to replace baking powder with yeast. Yeast is mainly used in breads as an ingredient to add a specific flavor and help the bread rise. Baking powder will never add a certain distinctive flavor to food so it can not match up to yeast in that way, but baking powder can make food rise. Yeast has a very specific flavor when added to food. This flavor can only be destroyed as bread-like and savory. If you try to replace baking powder with yeast it may not work as well as the taste of your sugary biscuits or sponge cakes may change dramatically from what they would have tasted like if you had used baking powder. 

When changing these two ingredients and replacing them for one another, the biggest difference will be the texture of what you are baking and then, possibly the taste.

baking with flour and eggs

Yeast Vs Baking Powder

Yeast is an interesting ingredient that can combine your mixture and give your recipes the ability to rise. In fact, yeast is actually a fungus but acts like a leavening agent.

As yeast is a fungus, the way it produces its carbon dioxide bubbles which is what makes food rise, is very natural. The process yeast undergoes to produce carbon dioxide is called fermentation. Fermentation uses the starch and turns it into gas, alcohol and water. A biological reaction which is vital in our cooking. 

When yeast turns the starch into alcohol the alcohol actually helps develop a lot of the other ingredients, like the gluten. This will help the overall flavor to the bread.

Yeast reacts very slowly and does require higher temperatures and moisture to begin its process. When you use yeast in your recipes it can react so well with other ingredients such as gluten sugar and starch and really bring out the flavor and height in your bread. The disadvantages to yeast is that it does require a slower process of baking. Yeast is very tasty in savoury items but it is not a good ingredient to use in sweet treats like cake and biscuits as it will not give a sugar-like taste.

Baking powder produces similar results but works in a different way. Baking powder is also a leavening agent and instead of making carbon dioxide in a fermentation process, it is made using a chemical reaction. This chemical reaction occurs when the baking powder is combined with other ingredients such as water.

Baking powder is naturally very acidic and is made up from acid and wheat starch. It is meant to be used in baked goods like cakes and biscuits. Baking powder is ideally for these kinds of bakes as baking powder reacts quickly and does not require a longer cooking time. Baking powder does not leave any kind of taste behind and does not react so much with other ingredients to bring out their flavors.

Both yeast and baking powder work in very similar ways as they produce the same reaction. These ingredients may be able to produce the same reaction but it may be harder to replace them with one another as they do have different advantages and different disadvantages.

Substitute For Yeast

Are you looking for a substitute for yeast  to use in your baking? This can be a tricky one as yeast is very vital in many recipes, especially when making bread. Yeast can make dough rise and also combine the ingredients. Using yeast can also give your bread and buns a specific desirable taste.

Here is the top three substituents we have found for yeast:

  • Baking powder: Baking powder is a key ingredient used when baking cakes and biscuits. You will most likely find that even if you are not a consistent baker, you will have baking powder in the back of your cupboard or somewhere in your pantry. Baking powder works similarly to yeast and helps the food rise. Similar to yeast, baking powder is also a leavening agent. Baking powder works by reacting with liquid as the acid inside of it will produce carbon dioxide bubbles. Baking powder can also react with heat as when it is heated to high temperatures the carbon dioxide bubbles will expand which causes food to rise and sometimes double in size. The main difference between baking powder and yeast is how rapidly they react, baking powder reacts quickly and almost immediately, causing it to react and make the food rise rapidly. Yeast works slowly to rise but can react in a bigger way. Yeast will always make bread rise larger than baking powder, but will take more time. Baking powder is the most simple bet if you are wanting to replace yeast in a recipe as it works very similarly to yeast,
  • Baking soda and acid: Combining baking soda with acid can help make an effective substitute for yeast. A baking soda and acid mixture can be just as good of a replacement as baking powder. When you combine baking soda and acid it actually forms a very close replacement for baking powder. The only difference with using baking powder as a replacement for yeast compared to a mixture of baking soda and acid, is that baking soda and acid will not make food rise as well. When we say combine baking soda with acid we would recommend using a citric acid or a dairy product. You could use lemon juice or lime juice a s citric acid or milk as a dairy acid. If you do want to replace yeast with a mixture of baking soda and acid it is best to replace every teaspoon of yeast that was in the original recipe with half a teaspoon of baking soda and acid.
  • Sourdough starter: The third option to finding a suitable substitute for yeast is sourdough starter. Sourdough starter is an ingredient that is actually found in yeast and is made from flour and water. The starter, like you probably guessed, is made to start sourdough bread. The sourdough starter mixture can help start the tangy flavor and trigger the fermentation that sourdough bread needs to gain its flavor and texture. Sourdough starter can work in the same way yeast does as the fermentation process will form bubbles of carbon dioxide. These bubbles are what make the dough grow and rise. We would recommend that you use half a cup of sourdough starter to replace every 2 tablespoons of yeast in your original recipe. These are all fantastic subtitles but some can be more effective than others. To start, we would recommend trying out the baking powder substitutes, then the sourdough starter and then the baking soda mixed with acid.
dough and hands

Instead of…

Can I Use Baking Powder Instead Of Yeast For Bread

When you are making bread, yeast is a vital ingredient to make sure that the load of bread rises and has a certain taste. Though there are replacements that can be used like self raising flour, beer and baking powder!

Baking powder does work as a clever substitute for yeast in baked goods, especially bread and cakes. It is best to replace the yeats in your original recipes with the exact same amount of baking powder. Baking powder will not give you the same amount of rise to your loaf. But it is a great substitute if you can not use yeast.

Can I Use Yeast Instead Of Baking Powder For Pancakes

It is easy to swap baking powder for it’s substitute yeast, as long as you get the measurements right! For every 1 teaspoon of baking powder that was in your original pancake mix recipe, you should replace it with half a teaspoon of yeast. Yeast can have its disadvantages and was not designed to be used in a pancake mixture. Often people like their pancakes to be sweet and fluffy and yeast can make them stodgy and sour tasting. There is no real way of changing this if you are wanting to avoid bad effects yeast will have  on your  pancake mix. The only thing you can do to help this is to add a little more sugar. 

You can replace baking powder for yeast when making pancakes. But we do not see why you would want to as you can actually get away with not using both! If you stick to the core ingredients in your pancake mixture (which is eggs, milk and flour), your pancakes will turn out just fine.

If you do not want to use baking powder in your pancake mixture, we recommend not using anything new at all. Stick to the core ingredients.

Magic in the kitchen of a pastry chef

Can I Use Yeast In Sponge Cake Instead Of Baking Powder

It is possible to use yeast in a sponge cake rather than using the traditional option such as baking powder. Replacing baking powder with yeast to make any kind of baked good would require the same kind of skill set as baking bread. Therefore substituting other ingredients with yeast could be a dodgy experiment. You may need a little practice before it is one hundred percent right.

Baking soda will take less time when making a sponge cake and using yeast can make the cooking process slower. The taste of the sponge cake may alter if you use yeast instead of baking powder. Although, the taste may change but it is dependent on what the flavor of the cake will be. If you are making a chocolate, coffee cake or something with a strong flavor then the yeast may not make a noticeable taste change. If you make a plain sponge or red velvet cake, then the yeast may make quite a big change in taste.

Can I Use Yeast Instead Of Baking Powder For Biscuits?

Yeast is great when baking bread but will not work as well for biscuits. Biscuits tend to be on the sweeter side. Yeast can have a slightly sour taste which is unusual in sweet goods like cakes and biscuits.

If you are looking for a healthier option compared to baking powder, yeast is actually perfect. Therefore if you do not mind compromising a little bit of quality for a healthier biscuit, then  yeast may be the way to go for you. 

Can I Use Baking Powder Instead Of Yeast For Buns

When baking any type of bread, it is possible to replace yeast with the same amount of baking powder and not notice the difference in the end result. Although, if you do decide to use baking powder instead of yeast when making buns, the rise on your buns may not be as obvious as they would have been with yeast. This lack of rise is due to baking powder not having the same leavening effects as yeast. Baking powder can make bun rise very quickly, but not to the height yeast would have allowed them to rise to.

stainless steel cup with brown powder

Can I Use Baking Powder Instead Of Yeast For Pizza Dough

Yes! You can use baking powder instead of yeast when making a pizza base. Baking powder can actually give you pizza dough a bit more texture than if you were to use yeast. Using baking powder in your pizza dough can give your pizza crust height when it rises. If you are using baking powder instead of yeast when making your pizza dough, you can add a little bit of sugar. This will add to the flavor and help create a brown colored crust. 

Can I Use Yeast Instead Of Baking Powder In Buttermilk Pancakes

Just like normal pancakes, you can get away with not using yeast or baking powder when combining the ingredients. If you do want a rising agent, you can replace baking powder with yeast when making buttermilk pancakes. In a buttermilk pancake recipe, yeast will act very similarly to baking powder. If you would like to replace baking powder with yeast, it is best to use the same amount of yeast as you would have with baking powder.

Can I Use Yeast Instead Of Baking Powder For Muffins

As yeast and baking powder are very similar, when baking muffin you can use yeast instead of baking powder. When switching baking powder for yeast, the recipes that will produce the best results will be recipes including dough. Recipes to make bread, pancakes or muffins will work very well if you switch out baking powder for yeast. 

Blueberry Muffin.

Can I Use Yeast Instead Of Baking Powder For Cake

Yes, you can use yeast instead of baking powder to make cake but there may be some problems along the way. Yeast can give a sour flavor to food, especially cake. Yeast may also cause your cake not to rise as you would expect. Baking powder is the safest bet over yeast when making cakes. If you do not want to use baking powder, there are other alternatives other than yeast that can be used. The other alterices such as baking soda may not give the cake a sour taste.

FAQS

Can I Use Baking Powder Instead Of Yeast?

The quick answer to this question is yes! You can use baking powder instead of yeast, but it really does depend on what you are making. Sometimes you may be able to get away with not using baking powder and yeast. If you are going to use baking powder instead of yeast, it is best to stick to the same amount used. 

Baking Powder Can Be A Great Replacement For Yeast

It is true, you can replace yeast with baking powder and sometimes it can work brilliantly. Depending on the recipe you are making, replacing yeast with baking powder does not have too many disadvantages. If you do decide to use baking powder instead of yeast, you may not be able to get the same kind of rise in your loaf of bread. But luckily the taste should not change too dramatically. 

Do you replace yeast with baking powder?

Related Posts on the Blog:

By Anna

Hey, I’m Anna; writer, editor and amateur cook extraordinaire! Food has been my life and my passion for the most of my life – it’s crazy to think I didn’t pursue a career in cooking. I’m obsessed! However, keeping cooking as an obsessive hobby has worked for me – my passion grows as the years pass by – maybe I wouldn’t say the same if it was also my day job! I hope you find cooking inspiration, entertainment and “stop and think interesting tid-bits” throughout my writing – and I’d love to hear from you if you’ve got anything you want to share. Food feeds the soul – so get eating!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.